Letters to the Editor for September 20, 2013

Union Democrat staff

Frog protection

debate continues

To the Editor:

Julia Stephens (Letters Sept. 12) says "Few, if any, new projects will ever be proposed in wilderness areas or in the extremely high, remote other areas adjacent to wilderness."

Exactly. Very few human activities are currently allowed in California's wilderness areas. I've backpacked a lot of these wilderness areas, and the limited human impacts are inconsequential in the context of the huge land area. So what benefit to the frogs will critical habitat designation have? None. So why pursue it? (This whole process has been 10 years in the works.) For ulterior motives.

David Hough of the CSERC (Letters Sept. 13) bemoans the destruction of meadows by drivers and littering in the national forests. Littering is illegal, and it would be fine with me if ATV's were completely banned from federal lands. Just address those issues specifically, instead of using the ESA to forward your agenda. Because that's exactly what is being done. Other than eradicating some trout, nothing that can be done under the ESA will benefit frogs, because it won't affect any of the causes of the frog's decline. But a lot of prohibitions of current uses will be incorrectly rationalized and implemented, just like with spotted owls.

The final proof of the real intentions behind the frog agenda is the massive land area up for critical habitat designation. One tenth the area would be more than enough to realize whatever few benefits there may be for the frogs. Why not drop this whole ESA frog charade and use the wilderness areas as a laboratory by continuing to eradicate trout in a few carefully chosen lakes?

Scot Turner


The Union Democrat
This image is copyrighted.

Reach all of Sonora, Calaveras County, Tuolumne, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, & Jamestown with your items to sell.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds Place an Ad

Connect with The Union Democrat

Union Democrat Newsstand

Thursday October 27, 2016

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour

More Publications by The Union Democrat

View All Publications
Submission policy


The Union Democrat welcomes letters for publication on any subject as long ... more

Letters to the Editor for October 22, 2016


Make your vote count To the Editor: It seems like Republicans, Democrats ... more

The third candidate for U.S. president


Hillary Clinton is a manipulative, power-mad liar. Donald Trump is a selfish, ... more

Insults, pandering offer no solutions


No issue has generated more heat in this year's presidential election than ... more

Measure would allow local affordable housing


Tuolumne County has its own ballot measure this year. Believe it or ... more