Letters to the editor for July 29, 2013

Union Democrat staff /

Biologists, bureaucrats will rule over frog issue

To the Editor:

Re: Union Democrat article July 18 "McClintock sets frog hearing"

While backpacking in 2009, my family visited McCabe Lakes in Yosemite. Middle McCabe lake had fish killing nets strung across it, with no live fish anywhere to be seen. We ran into a gentleman who turned out to be the biologist in charge of restoring the frog habitat of this lake. He explained that trout of all varieties are not native to any Sierra lakes with waterfalls below them, and were only there because humans had planted them. He mentioned that more than 10,000 fish had been caught and killed in this lake as part of the restoration. He said that trout killed frogs. My own thinking is that the Sierras are fairly vertical as mountains go, with waterfalls below many lakes, making those lakes designate-able as critical habitat for frogs.

How would this practice apply to potentially one third of Tuolumne county (per article) that would be designated critical frog habitat? I don't know, but once this designation is in effect, biologists and bureaucrats will be in charge with no practical recourse for the public. The insane measures required for protection of the elderberry beetle are a clue to where these critical habitat designations can end up. The fight over the handmade stone and concrete dams in the Emigrant Wilderness is another example of how these issues can play out.

I have no love for the Western Mining Alliance which is opposing this, but the huge area affected makes this an onerous proposal. I plan on being at the meeting at the Sonora fairgrounds at 2 p.m., August 6.

Scot Turner


The Union Democrat
This image is copyrighted.

Reach all of Sonora, Calaveras County, Tuolumne, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, & Jamestown with your items to sell.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds Place an Ad

Connect with The Union Democrat

Union Democrat Newsstand

Monday May 30, 2016

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour

More Publications by The Union Democrat

View All Publications
Letters to the Editor for May 27, 2016


Creating Sonora’s future To the Editor Reading Elena Linehan’s letter (“Beyond the ... more

Bernie Sanders deserves space and respect


You’re Bernie Sanders, and you’ll turn 75 on Sept. 8. You are ... more

GOP in danger of becoming No.3 choice in state


Even before Californians at last start marking absentee ballots this month or ... more

Bill Cosby, from victomizer to victim


There is no doubt in my mind that Bill Cosby did a ... more

And so summer begins


Memorial Day weekend marks the unofficial start of summer, three days that ... more