Columbia School Board of Trustees should be replaced

Union Democrat staff /

Shame on the Columbia Elementary School District Board of Trustees.

In an increasingly common show of contempt for the good of students and constituents, trustees in a single hour-long meeting last Tuesday failed to address the biggest issue on campus - Superintendent John Pendley's son sexually exploiting a student in a classroom - and even approved a policy that will compromise the safety of students in the misguided belief the district can revise history to save face.

Who exactly do these people represent?

It's not the community at large.

Trustees have shown an unwavering loyalty to Superintendent John

Pendley to the extent they have declined to discuss what happened on

campus publicly, have fought tooth and nail to hide public records, and

have snubbed questions raised by the public about what exactly is

happening on campus - specifically, will anyone be punished and will

any policies to prevent such abuse be adopted?

No. Instead, Tuesday's meeting was conducted in a manner designed to avoid the public's participation.

At least a few audience members were dumbfounded when they were

asked by President Laura Phelan to identify themselves, and that was

the extent of the input invited.

Phelan opened and closed the meeting's "public comment" portion faster than you can say "public comment."

Do the trustees represent the students?

Again, no.

Trustees adopted a policy Tuesday that says the district will no

longer require teaching aides, before starting their jobs, to have

CPR/first-aid training and a passing score on an academic proficiency

test. Brennan Pendley, hired as an aide with his father's help, lacked

both and, to the consternation of some district officials, this

newspaper brought that to the public's attention.

Thanks to this new policy, parents (including those in the PTA,

many of whom have thrown their support behind John Pendley) should pray

no child has an asthma attack, chokes, or suffers any other immediate

medical emergencies in an after-school classroom.

Beyond that, they should hope their kids won't need homework help

from someone who has no demonstrated competence in basic math and


Then there's the matter of the abuse victim, an apparently troubled 15-year-old girl.

Not one trustee has spoken on her behalf. President Phelan, in

fact, even had the audacity to defend Brennan Pendley in a letter to

Judge James Boscoe urging leniency in sentencing.

If school trustees derive their power by representing the interests

of the public and students, as the California School Boards Association

suggests, then this board lacks the mandate and moral authority to


For the good of the community, and kids, they need to resign.

Either that, or voters need to strip them of their authority in the

next election.

The Union Democrat
This image is copyrighted.

Reach all of Sonora, Calaveras County, Tuolumne, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, & Jamestown with your items to sell.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds Place an Ad

Connect with The Union Democrat

Union Democrat Newsstand

Saturday May 28, 2016

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour

More Publications by The Union Democrat

View All Publications
Bernie Sanders deserves space and respect


You’re Bernie Sanders, and you’ll turn 75 on Sept. 8. You are ... more

GOP in danger of becoming No.3 choice in state


Even before Californians at last start marking absentee ballots this month or ... more

Letters to the Editor for May 27, 2016


Creating Sonora’s future To the Editor Reading Elena Linehan’s letter (“Beyond the ... more

Views of all types welcome, wanted


The relationship between an editorial page and the rest of the newspaper ... more

Letters to the Editor for May 24, 2016


Fire agreement response To the Editor: RE: Response to May 18, 2016, ... more