Judges should not be deciding to cap prison population


By now we're used to it: Federal judges managing California's overcrowded prison system because administrators and legislators have failed to do the job.

Judicial intervention is often spurred by inmate lawsuits claiming that the way they are treated behind bars is cruel, unusual or otherwise illegal. Sometimes it is warranted, as conditions in California's 32-facility prison system have slipped as its population has risen to nearly double capacity.

But the specter of a court-ordered inmate population cap and the consequent release of tens of thousands of prisoners has rightfully galvanized opposition on the county level. Sheriffs and district attorneys from throughout California have asked that a three-judge panel appointed to address prison crowding hold off until a $7.8 billion plan proposed by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and the Legislature is given a chance to work.

Tuolumne and Calaveras county prosecutors and cops are behind the move.

"It would just completely overload every sheriff up and down the state," said Tuolumne County Sheriff Jim Mele of the feared inmate cap.

He's right: Although a cap and the mass-release of inmates would almost instantly ease prison crowding, it would come at a prohibitive price. The discharged prisoners have to go somewhere, and neither of the two alternatives on the street or in already jammed county jails is acceptable.

Sure, the inmates to be released would be "low risk." But the term is relative: That they are in prison at all means they were convicted of at least one felony, that a judge decided that bargaining it down to a misdemeanor was unjustified and that no combination of probation and county jail time proved an acceptable alternative to prison.

The bottom line: These inmates, as everyone in the criminal justice system agreed, should serve their time in prison and not on Sonora's Washington Street or Angels Camp's Main Street.

But why not simply transfer them to the county jail, a devil's advocate might ask.

A look at the old and cramped jails in Tuolumne and Calaveras counties answers that question. Both are small and unable to accommodate even the criminals of our own communities. In Calaveras County, and to a lesser extent Tuolumne, limited capacities lead to a "revolving door" situation in which inmates are released after serving only a small fraction of their sentences or, in some cases, no time at all.

Add just released state inmates to the mix, and our jails would have to release even more criminals to make room for the influx of prison transfers. The message, already on the street, would become even louder: If you do crime, you won't have to do the time.

Judges charged with managing our 173,000-inmate system should not adopt a simplistic inmate cap that will only pass the problems down to county jails even less able to handle them. Any judicially imposed solution should see beyond the prison walls and to consequences at the local roots of the criminal justice system.

But first, as sheriffs and DAs around the state have suggested, let's give Gov. Schwarzenegger's $7.8 billion, 53,000-bed prison expansion plan a chance to work.

Union Democrat editorial positions are formed through regular meetings of the newspaper's editorial board Publisher Geoff White; editor Teresa Chebuhar; managing editor, news Craig Cassidy; senior reporter-columnist Chris Bateman.

The Union Democrat
This image is copyrighted.

Reach all of Sonora, Calaveras County, Tuolumne, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, & Jamestown with your items to sell.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds Place an Ad

Connect with The Union Democrat

Union Democrat Newsstand

Sunday February 26, 2017

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour

More Publications by The Union Democrat

View All Publications
Letters to the Editor for February 23, 2017


Sweet Schadenfreude To the Editor: Lefties have decided to “resist” by burning, ... more

Letters for February 22, 2017


Standing Rock To the Editor: Beginning in April 2016 at the Sacred ... more

New Rules, Same Humans


On Tuesday morning, less than an hour after U.S. officials deported Guadalupe ... more

On pot, kindness, water and McClintock


Bravos Reprieve — The Calaveras County Board of Supervisors took a collective ... more

Is a Trump-Putin Detente Dead?


Among the reasons Donald Trump is president is that he read the ... more