Public blasts TUD fee subsidy

Chris Caskey, The Union Democrat /

The Tuolumne Utilities District will continue to examine whether it makes sense to lower connection and capacity fees for future developers in an attempt to spur growth.

Multiple people criticized the idea during a Tuesday meeting of the TUD Board of Directors, though board members said they are considering lowering the fees and want more information on how it could impact TUD's water supply and bottom line.

The idea, according to directors and meeting documents, would be to significantly reduce up-front fees the district charges builders based on costs to connect to the TUD system and on a new development's impact on the system. Though there is no formal proposal on the table, directors said they are interested in exploring possibilities like cutting the fees that can add up in excess of a million dollars by half or allowing installment payments over an extended period.

Members of the board backing the concept say a temporary reduction in fees would stimulate growth in the district by cutting costs for builders. In the long run, Board President Mike Sarno said, more growth means more customers and more revenue.

"To continue to maintain and fund our costs, we either have to cut costs dramatically, increase rates or increase revenue," Sarno said.

The fees are calculated for individual projects based on their impacts on the TUD water infrastructure, including storage tanks, treatment plants and water mains. TUD General Manager Pete Kampa told the board that state regulations control the fees to some extent. Kampa suggested TUD further investigate what parts of the system have what levels of capacity, look into where the district has committed water and sewer, and nail down other details it will need to know before proposing a full plan to reduce those fees.

"This is going to take some staff time, still," Kampa said to the directors.

Even without a proposal on the table, members of the public lined up to warn TUD about such a move. Speakers used terms like "sweetheart deal" to describe a discount, and suggested the district should not cut costs for developers at the expense of the TUD system and current customers. Jerry Cadagan called it a "reverse Robin Hood-ism" where the developers would receive benefits paid for by ratepayers.

"If a development project really has merit, the developer should be willing to pay legitimate costs and fees," Cadagan said.

While the proposal would be general change to the fees, members of the public brought up a pending apartment complex proposed for Columbia. Under the proposal, developers Golden State Holdings and RC Equities are looking to build an 80-unit complex at Union Hill and Parrotts Ferry Road.

The developer has approached TUD multiple times seeking a discount in the connection and capacity fees, which would add up to between $700,000 and $800,000.

Multiple speakers said the fees are fair.

"There's a cost to doing business, and that's important," said Tuolumne resident Laurie Sylwester.

The board asked Kampa and district staff to analyze the issue further and report back at a future meeting.

The Union Democrat
This image is copyrighted.

Reach all of Sonora, Calaveras County, Tuolumne, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, & Jamestown with your items to sell.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds Place an Ad

Connect with The Union Democrat

Union Democrat Newsstand

Saturday May 28, 2016

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour

More Publications by The Union Democrat

View All Publications
Sheriff’s deputies respond to alarm at Sonora KFC


Tuolumne County sheriff’s deputies responded with guns drawn to a holdup alarm ... more

Avalon Care Center fined for patient death


Avalon Care Center in Sonora has been fined $80,000 by the California ... more

UPDATE: Probe begins in Don Pedro fire


Investigators began sifting through the rubble of the Don Pedro Recreation Agency ... more

Homelessness, high school and the Butte Fire


Cole Baisch arrived at Calaveras High School around lunchtime as the sky ... more

Deputies visit schools, build community ties


You would think Tuolumne County Sheriff’s Deputy Nate Yorston was Santa Claus ... more