Ruling an upset to Walmart plan?

Christina O'Haver, The Union Democrat

A Tuesday appellate court ruling could further upset Walmart's plan to create a grocery-selling "Supercenter" in Sonora.

The Fifth District Court of Appeal overturned a Tuolumne County Superior Court ruling that blocked an argument made by a mostly anonymous opposition group - the "Tuolumne Jobs and Small Business Alliance."

The group argued the city of Sonora cannot exempt the mega-retailer from project review requirements under the California Environmental Quality Act without voter approval.

The city early on had prepared an initial environmental impact-report after Walmart submitted its expansion application, and circulated it for public comment.

Then, in June 2010, Sonora resident James Grinnell circulated an initiative petition, written by Walmart representatives, exempting the retailer from the review if adopted. Grinnell collected valid signatures from 541 of the city's 2,489 registered voters - more than the 15 percent required.

The City Council four months later decided to forgo a special election, saying it would cost the city $7,000, and adopted the initiative as Ordinance No. 796.

The state Elections Code allows the council to adopt the initiative instead of holding an election, but it must be done within 10 days of certifying the signatures. The period is extended to 40 days if the council opts to order a report.

The appellate court said the council could have satisfied both the California Environmental Quality Act requirements and Elections Code because it had already prepared an environmental impact report and was prepared to vote on it before the initiative petition was certified.

"Without an election, it simply is not possible to say that the people's will requires the important legislative objectives of CEQA to be set aside so a project can be expedited," the appellate court said. "Environmental review can be avoided when the voters choose to bypass it, not when the lead agency chooses to bypass the voters."

The case had been set for trial earlier this year, but was suspended pending the court's decision. The appellate court lifted the suspension Tuesday, so the case can now move forward in Tuolumne County Superior Court.

Court filings on Wednesday did not list a scheduled date for the next hearing.

Walmart hopes to expand its Sanguinetti Road store by 30,000 square feet, creating a "Supercenter" that would sell groceries and operate 24 hours per day.

Supporters say the expansion would bring in more job opportunities and sales tax revenue to a budget-strapped city. Opponents argue it would kill local business and destroy union-wage jobs at area grocery stores.

"We are committed to providing customers the broadest selection of products to meet their family's needs and will evaluate all options moving forward," Walmart spokeswoman Delia Garcia said in an email statement.

11883378
The Union Democrat
This image is copyrighted.

Reach all of Sonora, Calaveras County, Tuolumne, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, & Jamestown with your items to sell.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds Place an Ad

Connect with The Union Democrat

Union Democrat Newsstand

Sunday August 28, 2016

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour

More Publications by The Union Democrat

View All Publications
Woman dies of injuries in Highway 120 accident

08/24/2016

The woman who spent Monday night pinned in an SUV after an ... more

Convicted murderer Thomas Hyatt to remain in prison

08/23/2016

Convicted murderer Thomas Hyatt won’t be getting out of prison anytime soon. ... more

Three rescued from wreck near Yosemite

08/23/2016

Three German tourists were rescued Tuesday from the scene of a crash ... more

Jobs program seeks to help young adults

08/25/2016

Kristina Contreras was 18, a high school dropout, and the mother of ... more