Group appeals Bear Valley plan

Sean Janssen, The Union Democrat

A Twain Harte-based environmental group filed an appeal Tuesday to a decision by the Stanislaus National Forest to approve expansion plans for the Bear Valley Mountain Resort.

The Central Sierra Environmental Resource Center is challenging the Sept. 21 finding of Forest Supervisor Susan Skalski that an environmental assessment shows no significant impact as a result of the expansion plans.

The plan calls for the addition of two lifts to provide service between Bear Valley Village and the resort, an increased daily capacity of 810 people, upgrade of the Super Cub chairlift, 174 more parking spaces, construction of the 12,500 square-foot Bear Top Lodge and the addition of 85.5 acres of developed trails.

CSERC is not opposing the majority of the expansion plan actions as approved by the U.S. Forest Service but is appealing the decision because it doesn't require mitigation measures to reduce impacts to sewer infrastructure, forest habitat and greenhouse gas emissions, according to a Tuesday statement from the group.

The environmental assessment of the project lowballs the number of added visits to the mountain the bigger resort will generate, does not address the strain the added guests will have on the local sewer system, includes a "major amount of clearing and loss of old forest habitat ... to affect 'at-risk' wildlife species" and calls for no mitigation of "a huge amount of emissions" to be created by the project, according to the group's appeal.

Stanislaus National Forest spokesman Jerry Snyder said CSERC's submittal of substantive comments in a 45-day public comment period prior to the decision allow the group's appeal.

Pacific Southwest Regional Forester Randy Moore, in Vallejo, has 45 days to overrule, reverse or return the decision to the Stanislaus. Per U.S. Forest Service policy, Snyder declined to comment on the appeal's merits.

"Our center is highly aware that the Bear Valley Mountain Resort is important to businesses and the overall economy of Alpine County and the Highway 4 corridor in Calaveras County," said CSERC Executive Director John Buckley. "We believe that a solution to this legal appeal is certainly possible if the Forest Service actually wants a solution."

Snyder said CSERC can still meet with local Forest Service representatives to see if a compromise can be reached, and withdraw the appeal.

Bear Valley Managing Partner Greg Finch on Tuesday expressed dismay.

"We are of course disappointed by (CSERC's) actions in appealing the Forest Service approval of the Bear Valley environmental assessment. This will cause unwarranted expense and delay in our efforts to improve Bear Valley and it goes without saying that this will have negative effects on the entire (Highway) 4 corridor," Finch said in a prepared statement.

"The Stanislaus National Forest team spent almost four years reviewing and considering all aspects of the plan … Significant mitigation measures were added to the plan as the studies progressed and several key ingredients of the initial plan were eliminated to meet environmental standards."

"I believe that the Forest Service is confident in the thoroughness and legal integrity of its study and evaluations process and that ultimately the plan will be upheld," he added. "Having said that, we will plan to meet with CSERC and see if there are ways to address concerns - without taking the substance away from the key improvements we consider important to moving Bear Valley forward."

The Union Democrat
This image is copyrighted.

Reach all of Sonora, Calaveras County, Tuolumne, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, & Jamestown with your items to sell.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds Place an Ad

Connect with The Union Democrat

Union Democrat Newsstand

Saturday February 25, 2017

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour

More Publications by The Union Democrat

View All Publications
McClintock supporters, protesters call for peaceful event


With people speculating about what could become the largest protest Sonora has ... more

McClintock town hall draws large, divided crowd


There was patriotic singing, chanting and sign waving inside the packed 569-seat ... more

Diverse views outside McClintock Town Hall


They came with signs and flags and at least one mask, expressing ... more

County appoints working group on marijuana regulations


What do two county supervisors, a former California Highway Patrol commander, a ... more

Impounded water rushes into the Tuolumne River


Worried about rising waters in the Golden State’s sixth-largest water storage facility, ... more