Fuller files suit to challenge Berryhill run

By Margie Thompson, The Union Democrat, @margielou

A Columbia woman running for State Senate has filed a lawsuit contending Republican primary opponent Tom Berryhill can't run for the seat because he didn't move into the 14th District soon enough.

Columbia attorney Heidi Fuller, 46, on Feb. 4 filed a petition asking the Third District Court of Appeal in Sacramento to uphold and enforce a section of the California Constitution requiring candidates for the State Senate or Assembly to have lived in the legislative district for one year before declaring for office.

The 14th District comprises all or parts of Fresno, Madera, Mariposa, San Joaquin, Stanislaus and Tuolumne counties.

Fuller filed the suit against the Secretary of State and Attorney

General's offices, which she contends have not enforced the


The Attorney General's Office declined to comment, and the Secretary of State's Office did not return calls by press time.

Fuller is running against Assemblyman Berryhill, R-Oakdale, for the

Republican nomination to succeed Sen. Dave Cogdill, of Modesto, who

announced he will not seek re-election this year and is running for

Stanislaus County assessor.

Berryhill spokesman Steve Presson said Fuller's suit contradicts

legal opinions from the Secretary of State's Office, and a 1972 U.S.

Supreme Court ruling that struck down a one-year residency requirement

for Tennessee voters.

Presson said the Secretary of State's office requires candidates be

district residents when they file their nomination papers. Presson said

Berryhill moved from Modesto to Oakdale, which is in the district, in

early- to mid-January.

"Heidi Fuller's lawsuit is frivolous, politically motivated and completely without merit," Presson said Monday.

On her Web site, www.heidi4senate.com, Fuller posted a video-slide show calling Berryhill a "carpetbagger."

Fuller said her lawsuit is not frivolous, that "the vast majority

of districts have ruled the one year residency is constitutional," and

that "California has never considered the question."

"I'm not asking the court to make that determination, I'm simply

asking the court to enforce the Constitution," Fuller said Monday. "The

Secretary of State and the Attorney General don't have the authority to

declare a part of our Constitution null and void."

Fuller said the Attorney General and Secretary of State have two

weeks from the filing date to submit responses, then a hearing will be

set in 30 to 40 days.

Fuller announced her intention to challenge Cogdill in the 14th

Senate District last spring after his support of a temporary tax

increase in a budget compromise.

Berryhill's first term in the Assembly began in December 2006 and

he announced his intent to run for Cogdill's seat in early December.

Tim Campi, of San Joaquin County, has also filed paperwork to run for the Senate seat.

The Union Democrat
This image is copyrighted.

Reach all of Sonora, Calaveras County, Tuolumne, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, & Jamestown with your items to sell.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds Place an Ad

Connect with The Union Democrat

Union Democrat Newsstand

Wednesday May 24, 2017

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour

More Publications by The Union Democrat

View All Publications
No plea entered in case of Sonora doctor


Danny and Diane Anderson, a Sonora-area doctor and his wife who are ... more

Rose Wolf Wildlife Rescue needs a new home


A Sonora area nonprofit animal and wildlife rescue center that has helped ... more

Curtis Creek incident highlights danger of social media


Curtis Creek Principal Terri Bell’s message Thursday night to parents concerned about ... more

Tri-Dam plans public access day-use site on Tulloch


A public day-use site on Tulloch Reservoir stalled in planning stages for ... more

PG&E service backlog causes development headaches


Pacific Gas and Electric Co. representatives say winter storms are to blame ... more