Mistakes may cause charge to be dropped

archive_import /


A Soulsbyville woman convicted of second-degree murder in 2001 could soon be free not because she has been cleared, but because of legal snafus.

On Monday, Tuolumne County Superior Court Judge Eric DuTemple is scheduled to rule on a motion to dismiss the murder charge against Brenda Warne, 38. A jury in DuTemple's court in February 2001 convicted her of killing John Tocalino in July 2000 by bludgeoning him to death.

All along, Warne has contended she is innocent and that a former boyfriend was the culprit.

Now she is either going to get a second chance to prove she didn't kill Tocalino or be set free.

Warne has served 21/2 years of a 15-to-life sentence in the Central California Women's Facility in Chowchilla. But she is to be brought back to the Tuolumne County Jail, and will be in court for Monday's hearing.

There are two issues at hand in the Warne case:

? In February, the state 5th District Court of Appeals in Fresno overturned Warne's conviction. The higher court reviewed trial transcripts and ruled that DuTemple wrongly dismissed a juror during deliberations.

Francis Smith deliberated one day with fellow jurors but stood by her belief that Warne was not guilty, court records said. The other 11 jurors told DuTemple that Smith refused to deliberate further and the jury was therefore deadlocked.

The judge replaced Smith with an alternate, and Warne was convicted of second-degree murder six hours later.

But the appellate judges ruled that DuTemple should have declared a mistrial rather than replace Smith.

On May 23, Warne's case was returned to Tuolumne County Superior Court for retrial or dismissal a decision the county District Attorney's Office was to make. In February, Tuolumne County District Attorney Donald Segerstrom said there was "no question we will retry her."

? According to California Penal Code, the court and the District Attorney's office had 60 days or until July 23 to ask for a new trial. But the District Attorney's office failed to refile new charges against Warne by the deadline. Segerstrom admits his office made this error.

The Union Democrat
This image is copyrighted.

Reach all of Sonora, Calaveras County, Tuolumne, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, & Jamestown with your items to sell.

Ads appear Online and in Print

View Classifieds Place an Ad

Connect with The Union Democrat

Union Democrat Newsstand

Monday May 30, 2016

Read digital interactive editions of our publications

Read Today's Edition Take A Tour

More Publications by The Union Democrat

View All Publications
Sheriff’s deputies respond to alarm at Sonora KFC


Tuolumne County sheriff’s deputies responded with guns drawn to a holdup alarm ... more

UPDATE: Probe begins in Don Pedro fire


Investigators began sifting through the rubble of the Don Pedro Recreation Agency ... more

Tense board meeting ends in resignation


After months of turmoil between the Mother Lode Fair Board of Directors ... more

Avalon Care Center fined for patient death


Avalon Care Center in Sonora has been fined $80,000 by the California ... more

Homelessness, high school and the Butte Fire


Cole Baisch arrived at Calaveras High School around lunchtime as the sky ... more