>Sonora / Tuolumne News, Sports, & Weather, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, Jamestown | Union Democrat

News Classifieds Web
web powered by Web Search Powered by Google

Home arrow News arrow Local News arrow Walmart grocery foes lose challenge

Walmart grocery foes lose challenge

The Sonora City Council acted within the law in October 2010 when it waived any requirement for Walmart or the city to conduct an environmental impact report on the mega-retailer’s expansion plans, California’s highest court said.

The state Supreme Court decision released Thursday overturns a November 2012 ruling by the Fifth District Court of Appeal, which sided with the plaintiff, the Tuolumne Jobs and Small Business Alliance. The alliance argued an environmental impact report — a costly and time-consuming study of a project’s environmental, cultural or economic impacts — was required. 


However, speaking for the court, Justice Carol Ann Corrigan wrote that voter initiatives can be used in lieu of environmental reports, and that California law allows local governments to directly adopt such initiatives rather than hold an election.

“CEQA review is not required before direct adoption of the initiative, just as it is not required before voters adopt an initiative at an election,” the judgement states.

Walmart’s expansion plans will now go to the Tuolumne County Superior Court, where the parties will argue over whether the plan is consistent with the city’s General Plan, a legal roadmap for housing and commercial development.

Sonora City Administrator Tim Miller called the ruling “huge news.”

“It’s great news for the city,” he said. “It validates the action the City Council took.”

The case focused on Walmart’s plan to build a grocery section onto the Sanguinetti Road store. 

Though the city had started an environmental impact report for the project, Sonora resident James Grinnell gathered signatures for a local initiative in 2010 to exempt the project from the requirement. The initiative, written by Walmart, required 15 percent of about 2,500 registered voters in the city to sign a petition.

Initiatives often end up on ballots for voters to approve or deny, but state election rules also allow the local public body like a city council to adopt the initiative as an ordinance. That’s what the Sonora council did in October 2010, which led to the lawsuit filed by the mostly anonymous opposition group Tuolumne Jobs and Small Business Alliance.

The lawsuit asked the court to put the project on hold until an EIR could be completed.


For the complete story, see the Aug. 8 edition of The Union Democrat. 

Follow UnionDemocrat.com

Get Today's Top Headlines to your inbox

The Union Democrat print edition

The Union Democrat 11/24/15

View Paper

The Union Democrat is now online in a Replica E-edition form and publishes Tuesday through Saturday. E-Edition or Print Plus subscribers have full access.


If you are not a current subscriber, subscribe today for immediate access. Circulation: 209-533-3614

View all The Union Democrat print publications

Weekender by The Union Democrat

Weekly Arts and entertainment guide for Calaveras and Tuolumne counties

Weekender 11/19/15

View Guide

Available online every Friday or get it early in Thursday's print edition.

View past copies of the weekender

Local / Sports / Business / Stocks / News of Record / State / Nation/World / Obituaries / Submit News
Editorials / Letters
Union Democrat Photos / Community Photos /
Search Classifieds / Jobs / Autos / Homes / Rentals / Place an Ad
Online Extras
Weather / Local Business Links / Community Links / Photo Reprints
Union Democrat
About / Contact / Commercial Printing / Subscriptions / Terms of Use / Site Map

© Copyright 2001 - 2015 Western Communications, Inc. All rights reserved. By Using this site you agree to our Terms of Use