>Sonora / Tuolumne News, Sports, & Weather, Angels Camp, Twain Harte, Jamestown | Union Democrat

News Classifieds Web
web powered by Web Search Powered by Google

Home arrow News arrow Local News arrow Angels meeting guidelines too tight?

Angels meeting guidelines too tight?

There were no public comments Tuesday night at the Angels Camp City Council meeting, but if there were, could they be repetitious, slanderous or irrelevant?

That was the discussion among council members and City Attorney Derek Cole.

Cole, who works for a Roseville-based law firm, was previously asked to review and provide a legal opinion on the city’s guidelines on conducting “open and orderly” public meetings.

“Generally, I think these are good,” he told the council of the guidelines, which were adopted in 2005. “I think they’re legally accurate.”

There was one guideline, however, that did concern him: “No repetitious, slanderous or irrelevant remarks, or other disorderly conduct.”

“This limitation initially gave our office concern,” Cole wrote in a report to council members. “Prohibiting certain speech based on its content is generally considered unconstitutional.” 

The catalyst for reviewing the guidelines stemmed from a meeting earlier this year in which some speakers who “opposed the way the city was handling a special assessment” in Greenhorn Creek “expressed themselves in an angry manner,” Cole said after the meeting. 

Cole was asked by city officials during the summer to review the city’s meeting policies. 

“An issue with the city’s rule is the potential for misuse and impermissible application,” Cole wrote to the council. “It is important to note that a person cannot be prohibited from using repetitious, slanderous or irrelevant remarks unless it actually disrupts or otherwise impedes the orderly conduct of the meeting.

“In many cases, what may appear to be offensive speech may simply be a person’s way of expressing himself or herself. Indeed, the expression of anger, the use of epithets, and even the use of curse words can, in themselves, convey messages in ways that cannot be conveyed through calm or polite methods of expression.” 

Vice Mayor Jack Lynch agreed the council should change the wording of the guideline.

“The council has to be able to listen to criticism — that’s required,” he said. 

Cole said he will “tighten up the language” of the guideline to “recognize that criticism of public officials is acceptable” before bringing the item back to the council at a future meeting. 

Follow UnionDemocrat.com

Get Today's Top Headlines to your inbox

The Union Democrat print edition

The Union Democrat 11/28/15

View Paper

The Union Democrat is now online in a Replica E-edition form and publishes Tuesday through Saturday. E-Edition or Print Plus subscribers have full access.


If you are not a current subscriber, subscribe today for immediate access. Circulation: 209-533-3614

View all The Union Democrat print publications

Weekender by The Union Democrat

Weekly Arts and entertainment guide for Calaveras and Tuolumne counties

Weekender 11/26/15

View Guide

Available online every Friday or get it early in Thursday's print edition.

View past copies of the weekender

Local / Sports / Business / Stocks / News of Record / State / Nation/World / Obituaries / Submit News
Editorials / Letters
Union Democrat Photos / Community Photos /
Search Classifieds / Jobs / Autos / Homes / Rentals / Place an Ad
Online Extras
Weather / Local Business Links / Community Links / Photo Reprints
Union Democrat
About / Contact / Commercial Printing / Subscriptions / Terms of Use / Site Map

© Copyright 2001 - 2015 Western Communications, Inc. All rights reserved. By Using this site you agree to our Terms of Use